See who is already coming to #socialrecruiting summit in November!

Blog Network

Pick One: Specialization Versus Off-Limits follow this blog post

As a buyer of executive search, which would you prefer: a search firm that knows your industry like the back of its hand or one that is devoted to serving you and you alone?
 
In its early years, the consulting firm Bain & Company would only work with one client per industry to avoid potential conflicts of interest. 
 
I wonder whether a contrarian, anti-specialization approach might actually resonate with some VPs of Talent Acquisition.  I realize this flies in the face of experts who recommend that firms such as mine specialize in order to lure business away from the major retained search firms.  In fact, I've been told that specialization is the only way to do so. 
 
As neat and tidy as that seems and while specialization offers economies of scale, it poses a number of conflicts of interest. Moreover, specialization makes a search firm more vulnerable in whenever the economy takes a hit.  If your sector goes in recession, so then do you. 
 
I'd be interested in hearing whether any of you know of a firm that's refused to specialize in order to avoid conflicts of interest and off-limits list.
 
And I'd welcome discussion and comments on this and other "out of the box" ways to explore raising the bar, inspired by the realization, "there's got to be a better way!"

2 comments

Log in or register to post a reply.

  • 1 point 21 months ago

    Alison,

    Interesting observations. I think many employers have concerns that their own search firms may be poaching from them. Clearly the larger the search firm, the larger the off-limits conundrum.

    You make good points.

    Cheers, Krista

  • 1 point 21 months ago

    As a former employee of an executive search firm, I know that sometimes companies "bend" the off-limits rules, having it only apply to, say, the marketing function of a $250 million division of a Fortune 500 company, or only having candidates in a particular country as off-limits, or even only having candidates who are physically located at the global headquarters of the company with the off-limits label. Trust me, there are very creative ways of going around this... and you can also call someone "as a source" who is at an off-limits organization because "you are networking with him or her." So, you technically have an off-limits policy, but it gets a little murky as to the extent to which you obey it.