Register early and save on ERE Expo 2010 Spring in San Diego from March 15-17.

Blog Network

SittingXlegged

Corporate recruitment: what works and what doesn't plus other musings.

What Makes a Great Corporate Recruiter? follow this blog post

Exactly what personality, competencies, and experiences make a great corporate recruiter? No one person could possibly exhibit all of the qualities on this list. Each of us will exhibit some of the qualities but not all of them. The opportunity is to notice the areas where you excel and those areas where you could develop yourself.


Before we dive into the list, a quick word on the major sources of this information: I posted questions on LinkedIn, RecruitingBlogs.com, and ere.net. Follow the links for the great and varied responses from many of our colleagues.


And now, the list:


Customer service mentality-however you care to look at it, it's undeniable that we're in the customer service business. We have two groups of customers: our hiring managers and our candidates. Ideally we'd all keep everyone happy all of the time. That may not be possible but having a strong customer service mentality will go a long way to achieving that.


Compelled to provide an outstanding candidate and hiring manager experience-this is really more about customer service mentality but it's good to look at it from the perspective of the experience that others have.


Excellent organizational skills-corporate recruiters are responsible for a lot. When you consider the hundreds of resumes we review each week, the countless emails we read, the interviews, the meetings, and inevitable interruptions, it's a wonder we're as productive as we are. The only way we can be this productive is to have excellent organizational skills. Otherwise things will continually drop through the cracks, will take too long, and our customers won't be happy.


Strong administrative skills-our work must be accurate, complete, detailed, and prompt. We must understand that everything flows from the paperwork we generate while we're hiring a candidate. We may be audited by the OFCCPEEOC or some other organization. Will your files be the ones that cause your company to pay a huge fine? Are you creating messes for others to clean up?

Great at working with people-we're in the people business. We must love working with people and look forward to each and every interaction.

Exceptional at assessing people-we're not just processing stuff here. One of the things that exceptional recruiters have is the ability to truly assess a candidate's abilities and to know what a candidate will do when we extend an offer.

Good listening and interviewing skills-are we talking most of the time or listening? Truly great recruiters listen far more than they talk but when they talk they have something truly valuable to say because it's based on what they hear. This is equally important when working with candidates, hiring managers, and team mates.

Perceptive-being perceptive is a key part of assessing people. Have you ever had a candidate tell you one thing and do the complete opposite? The more perceptive you are the better you'll be at telling when someone is just blowing smoke.

Inquisitive-it's difficult to be a great sourcer if you aren't inquisitive. Digging through databases, running different searches, puzzling over possible places the ideal candidates may be hanging out are all things that light up an inquisitive person.

Works smart-there's a lot to do. Are you doing the most important work first or are you doing busy work and pretending that you're working hard?

Time management skills-do you have a plan to get done what needs to get done by when it needs to be done? If not you're just flapping in the wind.

Business oriented-we must satisfy the needs of the business. We're not a charity here and we exist, in part, to make a profit. Understand that unfilled, key positions are costing the company money.

More extraverted than introverted-we recruiters tend to be outgoing people. We have a thirst for human contact and we're natural networkers. It's difficult for us to stay holed up in our offices for days at a time.

Technically savvy-to be truly efficient we need to be expert users of all the available recruitment tools. Are your Boolean searches really searching for what you think they are searching for? How fast do you type? Clearly the faster you type the faster you can update your ATS and send emails and the more work you'll get done.

Ability to understand the requisition-Clearly we can't possibly be expert in everything we recruit for but we should be quickly able to grasp the essential parts of the requisition.

Ability to understand the skills and competencies required to do the job-skills and competencies are more than just words on a page.

Sourcing skills-as corporate recruiters we often have no bandwidth for sourcing as opposed to screening. When we have a critical, hard-to-fill requisition we need to find candidates. There's a lot more to this than running a few searches on your ATS.

Resume review skills-we could say that we look at resumes for a living. Great recruiters can review resumes quickly, identify strong candidates, and eliminate the unqualified candidates. Often it's what's missing from the resume that is most telling.

Closing and negotiation skills-it's a lot of work to move a candidate through the recruitment funnel. Strong closing skills maximize the percentage of candidates who accept our offers. Closing starts with the first conversation with the candidate and usually ends when they start work with us or decline our offer.

Be able to truthfully sell the company-closing isn't about making stuff up and convincing candidates to do things that they don't want to do. We all need to understand what's great about our company and where we have opportunities to improve so that we can sell the company in a fair and balanced way.

Persuasive-you'll use your powers of persuasion whenever you attempt to close a candidate on an opportunity or encourage a hiring manager to interview a candidate.

Hire for the future and for scalability-with every hire we make we are building teams of people. It's important to hire the right people that will make a positive difference for years to come. Today's candidates often turn into tomorrow's hiring managers. Are you hiring people who can continue to grow and develop their skills?

Relationship builder-our work is all about building relationships with our candidates and internal customers. Build strong bonds and great things will happen.

Flexibility-wait five minutes and something will change. We've all experienced doing a lot of work on a requisition only to have it be put on hold. As they say, "them's the breaks!" When something like that happens, do you let it ruin your whole day or week or do you get to work on the most important thing on your desk?

Tolerance of ambiguity-sometimes you won't have all the information that you believe you need and you won't be able to get it. You have a choice, stop work and wait or take some action and see what happens. Great recruiters will do the latter.

Understand the company culture-some candidates will thrive here and others will fail dismally. It's our job to understand what works and what doesn't.

Create business value-do your internal customers see you as an administrator or as a trusted business partner? You can't create value unless it's the latter.

Sense of urgency-Part of our job is to instill a sense of urgency in our hiring managers and our candidates.

Able to keep confidential information confidential-this is self evident

Integrity-in a corporate environment, any cutting of corners, untruths, or sloppy work will eventually be discovered.

Methodical-we have a lot to do and a lot of process to follow. A haphazard approach is not the best way to get the most quality work done.

Makes mutually beneficial hires-we're not just filling requisitions here! Every hire that we make should be the right thing for company and the new hire.

Knowledge of state and federal employment regulations-this is self evident.

Candidate control-is often associated with agency recruitment but it's equally important in a corporate environment. For example, do you know what other opportunities your candidate has, what their motivations are for relocating to the area, if they have support for the change in employment from their family? If you don't then you have little candidate control.

Have a thick skin-people say and do things that we often can't believe. It isn't personal and it isn't about you.
Ambassador-be an ambassador for your company in every interaction you have at work and away from work. You may be surprised what comes your way as a result.

Expert on competitors-the more you know about your competitors the better you'll be at working with candidates. Your closing percentage will increase and your sourcing abilities will improve with the more you know.

Understand that time kills all deals-this is the classic last but not least statement. Candidates have a shelf life. Business needs have a shelf life. To put that another way, if you wait too long your competitors will hire the best candidates and your business areas will find another way to get the work done without you.

15 comments

Log in or register to post a reply.

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Peter,

    Right off the bat I would say to your points "that a recruiter needs to be organized" and being a partner internally is needed for success are both accurate...and those would reflect in successfull KPI's...clearly...if you are taking those skills and applying them successfully to your job as a recruiter.

    2009 has been the year of survival for many in our industry.  HR leaders have had to fight for budget way more than they have in the past and also to even keep staff...many times to no avail.

    As a HR leader, you will not save anyone's job or move your team to the next level by telling your senior executives that your people have organized desks, hiring managers really like them, and they are great listeners.  Heck... you might not be even able to save your own job.

    I'm one of those who think 2010 will have us back on track based upon some conversations I have had with people and some other things...and hope.  Even with the layoffs that we have seen, it didn't cure the need for highly skilled/targeted talent and I think the game will be back on. 

    HR/Recruiters need to realize you are a business..and to know your numbers is to know your business.  Be both strategic and tactical in an organized way that you can "show" your business leaders..not just "tell" them.

    Even though HR has not in the past taken opportunity to "change the way things are done," I'm sure hoping they do this time.  In reality, I know a few are already...but I'm betting the majority or the status quo won't change one bit.

     

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    While I think while Sean makes a good point about KPI's being the key for measuing effectiveness, Simon hits it on the head here, in that there are SO many other components that make a good recruiter. I've seen great recruiters fail miserably because although they can sell dry ice to an eskimo [Innuit for those seeking a more PC term] ;), they could not stay organized for the life of them, and it cost them jobs in the end.

    Being a rock star closer, and making hires is great, but if you are not truly a partner internally, then you are replaceable. I agree with Sean sayin gbeing a jerk is not OK, but you have to have a personal/personable side to you if you really want the referrals to pour in, otherwise i think you fall into the trap of being viewed as a necessary evil in the step, in the candidates eyes.

    What we do is so diverse, that it encompasses the best and most demanding aspects of about 5 career paths (Think talent/sports agent, politician, supreme executive assistant, etc).

    We're a special breed, melting all these things together, and like any other chosen career path, it's all about pride in what you do. That's what keeps me getting up for work each day.

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hi  Peter,

    Nice! Pride in what you do should definitely be on the list.

    Cheers!

    Simon

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hey Sean,

    I'm sure they are all measurable to some extent although why you'd want to do that is questionable for many of them. Let's take extraversion/introversion. That's easily measured by Myers-Briggs or something similar. Good competency or behavioral questions will dig into many of the others. I'm not sure what you mean by "comparable" in this context.

    Cheers!

    Simon 

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Simon,

    I disagree with you on this one...I don't think any of them are measurable.  I think they are mostly "feel good" type metrics that are common in HR and part of the problem why HR is not take seriously by their business line peers.

    To me...and I'm putting this bluntly..what makes great recruiters is their performance/success and not how they are as a person. I'm not saying being jerk is ok...but performance is what counts.

    Lou Adler puts out the best and easiest KPI's in recruiting. 

    KPI stands for Key Performance Indicators (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_performance_indicator) and they include things like:

    1) Call Made
    2) Callbacks
    3) Candidate Creation
    4) Interviews set
    5) Referrals Gained
    6) Etc.

    KPI's are extremely common in work performance...except in HR areas.  However, as I say that...its great to see some corporate recruiting teams going this way and treating themselves like a business unit..because recruiting is a business made up of success/failures all through the day every day.  Even corporate recruiting.

    With the word "comparable" I am referring to allowing a recruiting manager/leader being able to tell who are the best people on their team.

    With the "qualities" you listed...those are subjective.  Recruiting KPI's identify the best...the strengths...the weaknesses...ROI's...and so on.  They allow leaders to lead, basically.

    Your post had great timing with me.  On this coming Monday, the recruiting team at Genentech is going live with a KPI based recruiting scorecard that includes both the sourcing side of recruiting and the applicant processing side of recruiting that I got to be a part of.  It scorecards at the individual and team level with approximately 60 sourcers/recruiters.

    Main categories include getting ROI out of event management, building diversity in their talent pipelines, quality of slate funnel metrics, time to fill, and what they are calling "Assists" which are those candidates that get passed around organizations.

    It is KPI's that make great recruiters for one simple reason...they give someone a target to shoot at or a finish line to cross.  Greatness is a goal, and all goals need to be defined at the most basic and measurable manner...that's what KPI's do.

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hi Sean,

    I'm all for creating meaningful metrics and it's entirely possible to manage a recruitment team from metrics. However, creation and management of a highly performing recruitment machine is way more than that! Your KPI list smacks of the worst of old school agency recruiting. There is one prominent national agency that still abides by this sort of thing and they are well known as aggressive slingers of *&%! I don't blame their recruiters because they can't go home until they meet their numbers. I blame their short sighted management. Focusing solely on metrics is a very narrow view. Organizations are complex beasts and there is just so much more to productivity than that.

    Here's something I like to keep in-mind that has made a difference for me:

    If you can see it you can move it

    If you can move it you can manage it

    If you can manage it you can fulfill on it

    Cheers!

    Simon

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Simon,

    I hear you on your points and also agree, it takes a combintation of leadership and knowledge of what is going on in your business to be a success story long term.

    I think the overall point I'm trying to make is that HR recruiting departments need to think of themselves as a business and act like one...if they ever want the respect of the business. 

    Acting like a business means you need to know your business.

    I once heard a senior executive at a major company refer to the HR recruiters as "newspaper boys."  They said this because they felt recruiters just deliver the news and have no impact on it or any contribution to it.

    Sadly, I knew exactly what he meant. 

    I love hearing recruiters say "we are tired of it and we are changing."  I hate hearing push back and people's "reasons" not to.  Take a guess at what I hear more of. ;)

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hi Sean,

    Guess we're on the same page afterall.

    Cheers!

    Simon

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Good stuff!

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hi Scott,

    Glad you think so.

    Cheers!

    Simon

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Simon,

    How many of these..if any...would you say are measureable and/or comparable?

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Simon - You're right, lots of good responses here and some good things to learn from this blog too! Thanks for getting this started!

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hi Paul,

    Thank you for your comment. What do you have to add and what was the most useful thing you learned?

    Cheers!


    Simon

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    I've read different articles on this topic here and there on the web and this is excellent!  Thanks for the insightful blog! 

  • 1 point 8 months ago

    Hi Nancy,

    I sure do appreciate the feedback. Glad you found it excellent and insightful.

    Cheers!

    Simon