See who is already coming to #socialrecruiting summit in November!

Blog Network

Networking is an Effective Recruiting Tool, Social Networking Not There Yet follow this blog post

A recent AfterCollege survey of college students and alumni provides valuable insight to help employers develop effective recruiting strategies.Traditional networking

We asked respondents to select the most effective methods for finding a job. Below are the options selected, ranked by popularity. Searching job boards and applying to company web sites directly were the two most popular options selected.

 

Traditional networking

Talking to people who work at an employer of interest, as well as talking to friends, family, and recruiters, were popular selections. These three options fall under networking.

 

Hard time finding work

We asked users if they were having difficulty finding work and unfortunately, the majority of them are having a a hard time. Only 4% of them had an easy time finding work. Those who had it easy We then focused on those who had an easy time finding work, and looked at their responses to the first question above on effective search methods. We saw some differences between the overall group of respondents and this select group in terms of what they found to be effective in their job search. You can see the differences below.

Applying directly on a company’s site and using job boards remained popular choices. However, talking to current company employees took the top spot (networking). Talking to friends and family, another form of networking, ranked high as well. Talking to professors and teachers was also a top choice, and the biggest differentiator between the overall group and those who found it easy to find work.

Those having a hard time finding work should consider talking more to professors. At the same time, employers wanting to get a leg up on improving their recruiting should consider working more with faculty, either directly, through AfterCollege (this is our model), or both.

 

How does social networking fit in?
We asked users to rate their usage of some of the more popular social networks. Over 80% of our users are on social networks, with Facebook taking the lead. However, only 11% of users found these sites to be effective in their job search. And out of those who found it easy to find a job, only 4% of them found social networks to be effective.

In Conclusion

Some recommendations to help you in your college recruiting and branding efforts:

Diversify your strategy. Students and alumni use various methods to search for jobs and different people find different channels effective. If your resources and budget are limited, prioritize your tactics based on what users find effective. Job sites are effective (make sure you choose the ones that target your desired audience), so is networking and so is making sure you have a good employment section on your web site for employers.

Leverage your employees and faculty. Since talking to current employees is a good way of finding work, make sure you give your employees incentive to talk to friends and family about job opportunities at your company. Many employers use employee referral programs (ERPs) as a way to do this.

Faculty at colleges and universities are also a good source for finding students and recent graduates. Make sure you develop relationships with professors at departments that graduate the type of entry-level candidates you are looking for (if you use AfterCollege to help in your efforts at your target schools and to help at schools that you are unable to visit, even better).

Use social networks, but not solely. Social networks are mainstream and will continue to grow in popularity. Use them. They offer a free way to share information with the masses and it's fun to update your company's profile and statistics on these sites. Be careful not to rely only on social networks though. While popular with users, job seekers did not consider them an effective channel for finding a job. Social networks are good for branding, but at the same time, they are a network to reach broad audiences. If this is your goal, great. But if your mission is to target specific types of candidates, make sure you follow up your use of social networks with media that will drive the desired audiences to your site or to your social network page.

To obtain the full survey report, please contact AfterCollege.

9 comments

Log in or register to post a reply.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    I am not sure that this is an issues with just college students. I think that this study may be representative of a normal population of job seekers. Most people don't understand how to effectively network and rely on job boards because it's easy. It's easy to see the social value of social media, but most people just do not understand how to leverage social networking tools in a business environment or job search and how to effectively market and differentiate themselves online so that they stand out in a recruiter's online search.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    I don't know if it really means anything but as I looked at the pie shape above it struck me to wondering what percentage of a student body graduates with an A, B or C average?  I looked for the answers online and did not find them - anyone? 

    Also, what are the parameters these days for A, B or C?  Is there even a D grade any longer?  I ask because I found this as a seemingly-popular grading scale:

    A 90+

    B 80+ - 89

    C 70+ - 79

    I understand this may/may not be related to the scale above and does not at all address any of the important points being made here about social skills but it just struck me as curious.  Any help appreciated.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    Hello Maureen,

    I don't have data on GPA for all graduates. However, I can tell you that our survey respondents had mostly GPAs on 3.0 and above, and many had GPAs of 4.0. In this economy, I don't think having a good GPA is of much benefit unfortunately.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    "I don't think having a good GPA is of much benefit unfortunately."

    Isn't that something?  I wonder if "grade inflation" (if it does indeed exist) has anything to do w/ that? 

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    I believe the survey points out that:

    Although gen x,y & mellinials are the largest users of social networks, they are the least versed on mining those networks for contacts that lead to hiring managers

    That their college education has positioned them with all the critical thinking skills they will need to succed once hired, but none of the business & social networking skills that are material to the jobsearch.

    Employers with well thought out "Career Landing" and "Employment Branding" web pages will help the talented candidates they seek find their way to their interview process.

    I submit that social networks ARE rich with contacts that every job searcher requires to shorten the cycle time to hire. The lament is that there are currently limited resources available to train them on how to truely leverage the social network universe.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    Well said Art. To illustrate, I was recently contacted by a professor via linkedin to help a former student now a sales engineer who had graduated from a top engineering school similar to mine. He (the sales guy) wanted to network into Lily and saw I had connections. I told him no but showed him how he was connected directly to 20 lily employees who graduated from the same school..and one of the was a sales trainer. Ya gotta love it.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    This is a great article. I forwarded it over to my network on linkedin and facebook.  Thanks for posting it! I'm looking for a job right now, so it caught my attention. This gives me stats and charts... basically letting me and others know where to put their efforts.  Best, Rachelle Munson - Looking in South OC or San Diego, Ca-Inhouse Corporate Staffing/Recruiting Manager http://www.linkedin.com/in/rmunson shellsanclemente@yahoo.com

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    I'm surprised you didn't get more reaction to this Roberto.This is an important article and I plan to refer to it at NACE in my session.

    Your findings also confirm our collaborative survey effort from last year when students seemed clueless in connecting social networks with "talking with an employee". I continue to find students [not to mention those supposedly more mature] in need of guidance that social networking tools can be used to great effect in tracking down alumns who now work in target firms and getting them to be your employee referral.

  • 1 point 6 months ago

    Gerry, Thanks. We were surprised by the findings as well. I don't think it's so much that students are clueless, but rather, that they do tap friends and family, but in a real-world setting, and not online.